Log in

No account? Create an account
. ..: .: ..::.: ..:.:.....: ...::: ...::.

April 2011
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30

gwen [userpic]
Don't book with Morning Glory Inn, Pittsburgh!

Late February or early March, I booked a room with the Morning Glory Inn in the Southside for the night of the wedding. I thought that it might be nice on our wedding night to go to a nice Bed and Breakfast room, and perhaps gather at the Inn with out of town friends for late night chatting.

When I discussed these plans with the Inn owner Nancy Eshelman, she seemed pleased that we would consider her place as our after-wedding location. She went over the rooms with me, and I opted for a two-floor room (the Attic Suite) so that we could have people over for chatting purposes into the late night. We also let her know that we do live in the Southside nearby. She did ask why we did not consider having our reception there, but understood when we told her the number of guests. I did ask if I should make a deposit for our room, and I was told that we didn't need this.

A week or two later, two of our wedding party (one bridesmaid and one groomsman) decided to also book rooms at this location. When our groomsman was trying to book a room for him, his wife, and his dog, we discovered that Morning Glory Inn had reserved two rooms in my name, the room we wanted (which is also the only pet friendly room) and the Wedding Suite! We did get this straightened out, and I opted for a room near the Courtyard, thinking that the late night chatting could occur there instead.

Please note that all of this was discussed with Nancy. She knew very well that we were a wedding party, that we were all together, and that I had been planning to do quiet after-reception gathering at her location.

Time passes. Four months, to be exact. At 11:17 this morning, I get this voicemail:

Voicemail Message mp3

Hi, er, Gwendolyn ... Schmidt. This is Dave at Morning Glory Inn. I regret to let you know that we cannot honor your reservation on October 9th as we have a two night wedding that weekend. The Holiday Inn Express and the new Spring Hill Suites have availability. The Suites is 412 488 8003. Thank you.

I also check my email to find our groomsman had forwarded the email notification he received about same:

Date: Tue, 6 Jul 2010 10:45:53 -0400
From: Dave Eshleman <dave@retractableroofpittsburgh.com>
Reply-To: dave@retractableroofpittsburgh.com

Hello [groomsman],

I am sorry for the inconvenience, but we cannot accommodate your
reservation for October 9, 2010. May we suggest the new Marriott Spring
Hill Suites – 412-488-8003 or the Holiday Inn Express 412-488-1130. Both
are in the neighborhood and both have free shuttles.


Morning Glory Inn


Our groomsman had contacted them and found out that the Inn had been rebooked, yanking out all of our reservations.

I then called the Inn to find out what was going on myself. What I can recollect of the conversation is as follows.

Me: Hello, this is Gwendolyn Schmidt, you left me voicemail?
Dave: Yes, we cannot honor your reservation. We have booked the entire Inn for a two night wedding, and need your rooms.
Me: OK, but I made these reservations before them. You can just pull them?
Dave: The other wedding is giving us $14,000. We need your rooms to fulfill their requests.
Me: But, we're a wedding too. You're cancelling my wedding night?
Dave: That's life.
Me: How can you run a business like this?
Dave: You're right, this is a business. We run it like a business.
Me: I will be contacting the Better Business Bureau about this.
Dave: You do that.

The text in bold I do remember him saying very precisely. It was this attitude that really made me furious; "We're cancelling your wedding night reservations, that's life." Seriously? And he made sure to put extra emphasis on the word "business" when explaining to me what he was.

This is very shoddy business practices though. Why?

1) We live in the Southside, just a few blocks from this Inn, and two of our closest friends had booked rooms there. Had they been wonderful, they would have seen future business from all three of us: our two friends would have loved to stay there again when visiting us, and we would have been happy to recommend the place to other visiting friends.
2) Two of the people kicked out (the groom and the groomsman) are running a small startup company themselves. This place could have been a nice convenient place for potential clients or future conferences for their company. This is lost business for the Morning Glory Inn as well.
3) They knew we had a large wedding; this is a large network to start with, and further it implies that we have a lot of friends. Our word of mouth networking power is mighty, and our friends and guests will learn about this miserable experience. That is also potentially lost revenue.

I am amazed at the whole experience with this place. Honestly, if they had approached us with the attitude of remorse, one where they apologized profusely for the double booking and offered to help us find accomodations elsewhere, I would be much more forgiving. But it scalds me that I am told the other parties' price for their wedding in a way to feel like I should feel inferior for not spending as much at their location, and that I was literally told, "That's life." There is no remorse in this attitude, only snobbery.

In the end, we will have benefitted from this. I have been looking at reviews online for Morning Glory Inn and have discovered that if we had ended up there, we likely would have encountered problems concerning our late night gathering. Dave and Nancy seem to have a habit of micromanaging their guests. I am now sorry for the people who booked their wedding there.

I have managed to get a block of rooms at the Spring Hill Suites. The Spring Hill Suites have already treated me far better, and I have a signed contract. The only downside is that there were only 15 rooms available the night of our wedding; we are likely to need more. I am looking into the Holiday Inn Express for additional support.

I did contact the Better Business Bureau, as I told him I would, and registered a complaint. I forwarded that confirmation to him with a bullet point list of why he probably lost more future profits than the actual profits he made with the wedding he kicked us out for. I told him that I hoped he considered this in the future before displacing another wedding party like my own.

I just hope to get the word out to warn any of my friends (or their friends) of this peril: Don't book at Morning Glory Inn in the Southside, unless you like terrible service with a helping of attitude.

Current Mood: pissed offpissed off

BBB? That's fine, but I'd sue their asses too.

Re: BBB?

Suing wouldn't gain us anything, there was no monetary value lost, and I have no desire to stay there again.

I'm just making my experience as public as possible, so future potential patrons know what to expect.

(no subject) - (Anonymous)
Re: BBB?

Instead of suing, I would contact the state's attorney and file an official complaint:
(It's what the att gen is there for)

As well as the local Consumer Protection agency:

Bureau of Consumer Protection
6th Floor, Manor Complex
564 Forbes Avenue
Pittsburgh, PA 15219
Phone: 412-565-5135
Fax: 412-880-0196

sounds like you should write your own review gwen. As much as it sucks to be treated the way you were, in reading those reviews it looks like Dave may have done you a kindness without even realizing it.

My review at Trip Advisor is pending.

following your plight

My friend becky has retweeted about your experience and i felt compelled to do the same. I would absolutely add your two cents to the Trip Advisor site. It seems they are quick to defend their shady practices as "business" and are quick to blame everyone else in their responses. A call to your local news' consumer watch group might not hurt either. Regardless I have many friends that often travel that way and I will make sure every one of them knows not to stay at Morning Glory.

Re: following your plight

My Trip Advisor comment about this experience is pending posting currently. That process just takes a few days.

I am STUNNED that business owners don't always realize that their actions do affect them. Who cares how much the other wedding party spent. Honestly!!

Fortunately, you have other options. But its a shame that you had planned your wedding night and some schmuck was so insensitive about it!

We have rooms blocked at the Spring Hill Suites now, under our names. I'm looking into the Holiday Inn Express as well, details on that forthcoming.

I wonder how much business owners have realized that in this internet age, if you dick people over, you lose harder than ever before.

(no subject) - (Anonymous)

By the way, you won the lottery, just send me your account information.



I applied to them already. They're "reviewing my case".

I'm so horrified for you. I'm glad you're spreading the word about that place - that is absolutely not how you run a business. What a ridiculous attitude.

Ugh! I'm sorry to hear about that bit of superdickery.

To be honest, I'm not surprised. When Becki and I talked to them, we got one quote from them on the phone. It was reasonable. When we met in person to take a look, that was when we mentioned that it was for a wedding. Then they jacked the price up by multiple hundreds of dollars, and were going to make us use their catering instead of the one we already lined up.

I'm so glad we did our wedding at our home.

Retweeted and Facebooked

This story is truly shocking. As if wedding planning weren't already stressful enough.

Have a lovely wedding.


I've had the displeasure of interacting with them a few times. I used to go to the gym down there, and would sometimes park in front of the Inn. On several occasions, someone would come out and tell me that I couldn't park there. I was like, "Look, it's a public street. If you have some reason you need to block off parking, call the city and get a variance, or get it declared a no parking zone, or whatever, but until then, it's a public street. Sorry." I was sometimes vaguely afraid that my car would be vandalized, but it never was. Regardless, when people don't understand that street parking is a shared public resource, it's usually a decent sign that they "just don't get it," and that usually applies to more things than just parking. In this case it appears to apply to "running a business" as well.


Wow, thank you for this! I was considering this place for my wedding, but there's no way I'm dealing with that sort of crap. They are now officially crossed off my list thanks to you. Oh, and FYI, this blog was the FIRST result that came up on google for my search terms!


No problem! I'm glad it helped.