gwen (gwenix) wrote,

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Does this make sense to anyone?

Can someone explain to me how this makes sense?

Specifically, how is it that the Supreme Court is leaning towards deciding that someone who has been falsely arrested and prosecuted has to sue the police for false arrest while the case is still in the courts? That pretty much guarantees this situation:

A bad cop plants evidence, arrests someone on that planted false evidence. Perhaps the cop thought he was doing the right thing, perhaps he was just trying to close a case quickly for a promotion, perhaps he's corrupt and throwing the arrest delibrately to the wrong guy. Doesn't matter for the purpose of this story, he just does so.

The wrong guy is put through trial with the falsified evidence convicting him. He then spends ten years in court appeals trying to prove his innocence, it is finally proven at the end that the evidence was, in fact, falsified.

The cop still gets away with it, since if the man had tried to sue for false arrest in the first two years, his guilty verdict would be used against him guaranteeing an automatic loss. Now, ten years down the line he can show the falsified evidence, and thus that the cop planted evidence, but now it's "too late". Sorry, the cop can laugh happily, and feel free to continue planting evidence, since, well, he'll never be held accountable for it.

Further, the guy who has now spent a third of his life in jail instead of doing more productive things can't sue for compensation. He could have sued for compensation, y'know, BEFORE he knew how long he'd spend in jail... but we already went over the unlikelihood that he'd have been given that compensation at that time anyway.

How on earth does this make sense? Like, why is the Supreme Court leaning towards upholding this injustice?

  • Upcoming Spring Concert for RCC!

    Hi folks! This Friday and Saturday (April 29 and 30) I'll be in the Renaissance City Choirs production of "Love of Nature, Nature of Love". I'm…

  • If Schroedinger called in a bug..

    Scenario: Schroedinger has a box with a verified dead cat in it. He hands the box to customer support of a company, who later hands him back that…

  • Pumpkin Pasta recipe

    I actually cooked a good meal the other night. Like, this is miraculous. Further, it was VERY low pointage for Weight Watchers, and incredibly…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 1 comment